Long-Term vs. Vacation Rental on the Lakeshore: What Owners Should Weigh

West Michigan's lakeshore is one of the most popular places in the Midwest to spend a summer weekend. If you own a home in Holland, Saugatuck, Douglas, or nearby, you've probably wondered whether it should be a vacation rental instead of a long-term one.

There's no single right answer. Here are the main things to weigh.

The case for long-term rentals

A long-term rental, typically a lease of a year or more, is the steadier option. The main advantages are:

  • Predictable income. The rent is the same every month, which makes budgeting easier.
  • Less turnover work. You aren't cleaning, restocking, and photographing the place every few days.
  • Simpler day-to-day operations. You have one tenant to communicate with rather than a steady stream of guests.
  • Fewer rules to navigate, in many (but not all) places. We'll get to that below.

The trade-off is that you usually earn a steadier, but not seasonal, rent, and the home isn't available for your own use.

The case for vacation rentals

A vacation rental can bring in more during peak season, and it gives you the option to use the home yourself. But it's also more like running a small hospitality business. You'll be dealing with:

  • Frequent turnovers, meaning cleaning, linens, supplies, and inspections between guests
  • Seasonal swings, with busy summers and a much quieter off-season
  • Guest communication at all hours, from check-in questions to a Wi-Fi password
  • Furnishing and supplying the home to a higher standard
  • More wear and tear, since guests are on vacation and not caring for it like a home

Check the local rules first

This is the part to take seriously. Short-term rental rules vary by city and township, and they can change.

As one example, the City of Holland describes a short-term rental as a dwelling rented for fewer than 30 consecutive days per occupant, and it requires a Short Term Rental Certificate of Compliance. The city's Rental Certification & Licensing Guide explains that the rules differ depending on whether the home is owner-occupied or investor-owned, and that some zoning districts have caps on the number of properties allowed.

Saugatuck, Douglas, and the surrounding townships each have their own rules as well. Before you invest in furniture and photos, confirm with your local municipality what's allowed for your specific address. Also check with your insurance provider, since a standard landlord policy may not cover short-term guests.

The hybrid option: seasonal or off-season rentals

Some owners split the year, running the home as a vacation rental in summer and renting it long-term in the off-season. It can work, but it comes with its own wrinkles. Holland's guide, for example, says a property used part of the year as a short-term rental and part of the year as a standard rental must meet the criteria for both. Furnishings, utilities, lease length, and local rules all need a plan.

Questions to ask yourself

  • How much do I want to be hands-on? Vacation rentals demand more attention.
  • How much income stability do I need? Long-term rent is steadier.
  • Do I want to use the home myself? Vacation rental flexibility may be worth a lot to you.
  • What are the local rules and licensing requirements for my address?
  • What would the numbers look like after cleaning, supplies, utilities, and vacancy? Run both scenarios honestly.
  • Is the property set up for guests or for residents? A cozy cottage and a year-round family home aren't always the same thing.

A practical way to compare

Start by finding out what the property could earn as a long-term rental, since that's a solid baseline. Then compare it, after expenses, to realistic vacation rental income. The better choice is the one that fits both your goals and your tolerance for work.

Not sure what your lakeshore property could rent for long-term? Start with the baseline.

Get your free rent estimate from AMK →

Previous
Previous

Winterizing Your Michigan Rental Property: An Owner’s Checklist

Next
Next

How to Price Your Rental Right: A Simple Guide to Rent Comps